on a 2.4,  the other 3 are good,  under 10,000,  can i replace it with a old one from a older 2.4 with higher k's???  the bearing and rings will be new
 
i wouldn't risk it...its like saying i am gonna have 2 new valves and lifters but the others are gonna be old and moe likley to fail
 
 
but everything will be new on it,  new bearings and rings on all 4 pistons,  the engine will be rebuilt
 
The car I had had a piston slap at 30,000km. (Too much  piston to cylinder clearance from the production line) 
 
 
Dealer replaced the 1 piston (no over sized) without pulling the engine.  
 
Make sure the piston to cylinder clearance is to spec and re- hone and above all CLEAN  out all your stone dust thoroughly. 
 
PS I am now rebuilding at 360,000 KM! so don't let someone tell you is does not work!! 
 
Note this was a 2.2 , but your engine tolerances are similar