IamRascal wrote:I really wouldn't bother porting the intake manifold. It should be pretty close to the ports on the head already.
Don't know if you knew about it but Crate Engine Depot sells the manifolds from the 2.4ecotec if your looking for higher flow.
Mike85220 wrote:Thank you all for the tips on porting.
I am going ahead and will extrude hone this manifold though.
I understand that this is NOT as good as a header.
The output of a header and custom downpipe will be double the hp gain, but also will be double the price.
I just don't want any issues with the sometimes unknowledgeable police telling me to take my header off even if it is carb exempt.
I have seen the L61 manifold, and it is D shaped on the downpipe side.
The L61 manifold looks so unbelievably restricted.
This LSJ manifold is a big O shape on the downpipe side, and I have seen the pics of the extrude honed manifold that they want $250 for.
I paid only $25 shipped for this LSJ manifold!
That is 1/10 the price and I will do the porting myself.
Anyways, I know people with a Cobalt have been getting 3hp from the extrude honed manifold, and I personally wouldn't pay $250 for 3hp.
But... that is a 3hp gain over the Cobalt stock manifold, which is what I have and will be putting on an 03 Sunfire.
In 2007 all 2.2 Cobalts get the same manifold as the SS Cobalts, they do not make L61 manifolds as of 07.
I am hoping that the gains will be more like 5hp since I am:
1- trading up from the restrictive D shaped L61a.
2- further enhancing the manifold through porting.
I figure even if the manifold only gets 4 more hp, I only paid $25 for it.
I am told the manifold swap will cost me $50 labor.
I am also getting a 2 1/4 inch downpipe made up and was quoted $65 to make one at a local muffler shop.
I also have the gaskets and bolts which is a little more money.
All of this is around $170 or so total to get a little more flow out of my already 2 1/4 inch exhaust, not pricey.
Just a Pacesetter header alone is around $240 with armor coat, which is the only way to go if I got one.
Then factor in the $50 install (or more because I hear these aftermarket headers are not always plug and play, they need modified and fitted), plus bolts and gaskets, and cost of a custom made downpipe. That would be almost double or more what I am going to pay, but the output would be double from the header.
The downpipe should give at least a 3hp difference.
I know that I cannot just add hp together, but the output over the entire RPM band should be at least another 3-5hp.
After this I am getting a CAI, a strut bar brace, a K brace, and a set of 15" Trak Lite alloy rims that are only 10lbs a piece!
Of course this will be over the next 6 months and not at once, I am not rich.
Quote:
...its a stock POS cast iron manifold...
and you're making a custom downpipe but leaving the header alone? wtf... why dick around on the exhaust then blow $290 a wheel on lightweight track wheels?
your modding scheme makes no sense.. thinking way too hard over 2 hp.
DaFlyinSkwirl (PJ) v2.0 wrote:[your modding scheme makes no sense..
Quote:
and plug the hold in the manifold
Quote:
I am told the manifold swap will cost me $50 labor.
mike85220 wrote:I just don't want any issues with the sometimes unknowledgeable police telling me to take my header off even if it is carb exempt.
mike85220 wrote:I might be way off, but the car has liked the mods so far and I am only willing to toss a few hundred here and there for mods until they offer the supercharger kit on crateenginedepot.com for $1600 or so like they do for the 2.4 older Sunfire and Cav.
Quote:
...so whats to say the police won't be stupidand tell you to remove your supercharger..?
Quote:
what year is it from?
Quote:
so you have the tools to port the manifold but you dont have a few wrenches?
Quote:
your not going to spend money on a dyno run to ever find out if you gained 3 HP....if you even get that.
theres nothing wrong with what your trying to do....just dont try to justify it by comparing the HP gains.
Quote:
...so whats to say the police won't be stupidand tell you to remove your supercharger..?
Mike85220 wrote:Quote:
Honestly, since I have seen the stock Cobalt 07 manifold compared to the L61 it is a pretty safe bet that it would give at least 3hp more. I have read in a few places like CobaltSS.net and http://www.isuzuperformance.com/isupage/tech/build.html that just a port job on a exhaust manifold is a 3hp gain.
If I not only upped the manifold design wise, but further went on with a port job, it should be at least 5hp.
you still dont get it.....sigh
dyno proof from these places that youve read about 3HP gains. then your adding up HP like 2+2=4.
so if i made a post that said i gained 17 HP from my new muffler bearings, does that mean if i ported the tailpipe, i would get 4 more HP?
you dont want to spend the money on a header, so you sure arent going to spend money on the dyno and prove any gains from the manifold.
just do it and stop making HP claims
Mike85220 wrote:You obviously think I am a HP stacker -I am not... My claims are not like other people. I am stating some pretty low gains here.
I know most people for example who say their intake is 12hp, the header is 15hp, exhaust is 15hp, therefore they must have 42 more hp than stock. They are wrong... Only a dyno or a comparison of an old time slip at the track will tell how the mods helped...
I am not saying if the car was bone stock as an example that with the manifold and downpipe added I would on a 140hp car now have 143hp. I do know that I will have a gain at certain areas of the RPM band (lows,mids,highs) and sometimes hp goes down in one area and gains in another and so on. I know all about this phenomenon.
I know for a fact that there are people here and over on CobaltSS.net that have the 02-05 Ecotec 2.2s with a CAI, and header/ full exhaust that have 165 hp at the crank, and the dyno is saying at the wheels it is about 140hp. That is a 25hp gain, and not 42 like the HP stackers would have you believe. But the car has a lot more power throughout the lows, mids and highs due to these mods of allowing the motor to get more air in and be able to get rid of the exhaust faster.
Logically if a manifold is rated and dynoed 3hp over stock, it makes no sense that porting it 'wont' enhance those numbers. The only exception is if the motor design for whatever reason, the mod went past the point of helping and actually hurt performance. An example of this is having a 3 inch exhaust on a NA 4 banger with stock 140hp. Now there is not enough back pressure. With my mod I seriously doubt I am going against the motor.
The manifold was restrictive, the ports are now larger by design, and on top of this it is ported and thus it has even less of a restriction. Would you say it is still adding only 3hp??? Or would you say it is feasible it is more?
That was 'just' the manifold alone.
Now add a 2 1/4 inch downpipe...
Now how much much would you assume across the RPM band has the HP gone up? A measily 5hp? This gain is a lowball in my opinion, and if I am wrong which I sincerely doubt, oh well.
The stock manifold and down-pipe are the weakest link here on my exhaust, so do you really feel it is going to only stay at a 3hp gain with the better designed and ported manifold along with a larger downpipe? Saying 3-5hp as a gain at either the max output (not hard to picture) or as a consistent gain over the entire RPM band which is also not jumping the gun.
I do get it, sigh
Quote:
An example of this is having a 3 inch exhaust on a NA 4 banger with stock 140hp. Now there is not enough back pressure. With my mod I seriously doubt I am going against the motor.
Quote:
Now how much much would you assume across the RPM band has the HP gone up? A measily 5hp? This gain is a lowball in my opinion, and if I am wrong which I sincerely doubt, oh well.
Quote:
restriction and flow alone do NOT increase power.
header design has a lot more to it than diameter of the runners, the shape, the angle they combine at, the collector size, all have a lot to do with how it'll increase and help scavenge exhaust gases from the cylinders.
you look WAY too deep into a simple matter. buy a real header, or waste money and time. its that simple. A stock manifold that has a runner thats 3 inches long and smashes everything together almost instantly is not going to make as much power as a header with a 4-1 or even a 4-2-1 design.
you're assuming a LOT about flow characteristics.
Quote:
just because a port is larger, does NOT mean its better. Selt porting something does NOT always help.
Quote:
But I digress.. I have 3" exhaust on my n/a car and I mean we all know thats not enough backpressure for the engine... so, what do I know?
Quote:
you'll be lucky to see 3hp.
Quote:
lmao. you going to tune this setup?
Quote:
people here who have actually done track and dyno testing or who spend countless hours researching the topic.. talking with people who design custom headers for a living, reading books, etc...
Quote:
What is the best tool on the downpipe side of the manifold to port it?
What is the best tool for the head side of the manifold to port it?
How do I get into the piping to dremil it out too when it is so hard to get down in there?
Mike85220 wrote:Why not sit here and critique you then?
Ecotec L61 swap (why not just buy a friggin 03?)
Mike85220 wrote:Custom shortened RKsport intake (what? suck at shifting?)
Mike85220 wrote:SMS 69mm throttle body (now you gone and done it, the velocity of air is slowed with the huge ass TB and you lost your low end, and probably biffed your mids too)
Mike85220 wrote:custom modified cobalt OBX header 3" collecter 4-1 (WTF? all high end? What about the 4:2:1 to get your scavenged exhaust to not lose your low end?)
Mike85220 wrote:3" piping from header back (Think you drive a V-8? Where's your forced air induction?)
Mike85220 wrote:3" magnaflow high flow cat (High flow cat is a marketing scam, my friend owns a muffler shop and says they are all the same)I installed this to pass visual inspection for the state of NJ. Before that, I didn't have a cat at all
Mike85220 wrote:3" thrush glasspack (Same)
Mike85220 wrote:magnaflow muffler (should have gotten a Corsa, the Magnaflow sounds like a Honda)
Mike85220 wrote:ARP head studs (Need these to keep all that hp under raps, even though the stock will take 250hp)
Mike85220 wrote:
Patriot stage 2 head
LZM triflow cams
440cc injectors
Fidanza 7 lbs flywheel
SPEC stage 3 clutch
Mike85220 wrote:Autolite Platnium spark plugs (stock heat range) (LOL! Got to brag about plugs even though 90% of the people say platinum plugs don't run well with hot coils like the blaster coil)
Mike85220 wrote:RKsport upper motor mount (ac mount removed) (all this work and you could have bought an old 280ZX or an 80's F body with a 383 or bigger)
Mike85220 wrote:RKsport lower motor mount
prothane tranny mounts
removed air conditioning (could have kept this is you weren't being a big %$#)
Mike85220 wrote:HP Tuners (10-13 hp gains out of an Ecotec for $300+)
Mike85220 wrote:MSD 6212 ignition (waste, no hp gains)
Mike85220 wrote:MSD blaster coils (waste, no hp gains)
Mike85220 wrote:-that is what YOU sound like just so you know before you get all huffy about it.
Quote:
Myth?
http://www.querycat.com/faq/df21a24b8c9a0baf4a6822fb0c42f4fe
Alrighty, more like you bought a 3" exhaust and don't realize how much better off you'd be with a 2 1/2 for the mods you have.
Quote:
you'll be lucky to see 3hp.
http://www.isuzuperformance.com/isupage/tech/build.html
Look it up under performance building, and ask the people on www.cobaltSS.net how much they gained.
Quote:
I am right...sorry.
Your flipping out like 'Whoa he is talking a whopping 3hp gain from a manifold and blahblahblahblah
blahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblah
blahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblah
blahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblah
blahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblah
I got what I needed from this post but my car will still be slower than daflyinskwirl anyway.